Compare
Compare Shopify subscription apps
Side-by-side comparisons based on public App Store listings and vendor docs. Competitor names are trademarks of their owners. We position SMART as the clearer fit for a focused subscribe and save setup.
SMART Subscriptions vs Appstle
SMART Subscriptions is free at any revenue. Appstle is free to $500/mo in subscriptions, then $10-$100/mo, with Build-a-Box and product swaps.
SMART Subscriptions vs Recharge
SMART Subscriptions is free. Recharge costs $25/mo (fee-free for 50 subscribers), $99/mo + 1.49% + 19¢ or $499/mo + 1.34% + 19¢ on a 12-month term.
SMART Subscriptions vs Seal
SMART Subscriptions is free for any number of subscribers. Seal is free to 50 subscriptions, then from $5.95/mo by subscription count, with 0% fees.
SMART Subscriptions vs Kaching
SMART Subscriptions is free. Kaching has no transaction fees but costs $9.99-$299.99/mo by subscription revenue, with portal swaps and auto swaps.
SMART Subscriptions vs Loop
SMART Subscriptions is free, prepaid plans included. Loop is free to 50 active subscriptions, then $99/mo + 1% or $399/mo + 0.75% (prepaid on Pro).
SMART Subscriptions vs Shopify Subscriptions
Both apps are free. Compare plan options, pay in advance, retries, emails, CSV import and customer self-service in SMART and Shopify Subscriptions.
SMART Subscriptions vs Recurpay
SMART Subscriptions is free. Recurpay costs $9, $19 or $99/mo with 0% transaction fees, and adds build-a-box, bots, swaps and white-glove migration.
SMART Subscriptions vs Joy
SMART Subscriptions is free with no subscriber limit. Joy is free to 50 active subscriptions, then Starter $49/mo + 0.75% or Pro $199/mo + 0.5%.
SMART Subscriptions vs Bold
SMART Subscriptions is free. Bold runs from $24.99/mo + 2% to $399.99/mo + 0.9%, with cancellation flows, dunning, APIs and white-glove migration.
SMART Subscriptions vs Skio
SMART Subscriptions is free. Skio Scale is $599/mo ($499/mo billed yearly) + 1% + 20¢ per order, with journeys, cancel flows and Build-a-Box.
SMART Subscriptions vs Stay AI
SMART Subscriptions is free. Stay AI is $499/mo, or $299/mo on an annual contract, plus 1% + 19¢, with churn tools, smart dunning and an account manager.
SMART Subscriptions vs PayWhirl
SMART Subscriptions is free. PayWhirl is free to install with 0% on the first $5,000 then 3%, or $9-$149/mo plans charging 0.75% to 2% per order.
Prefer to try SMART first?
Install SMART Subscriptions and set up your first plan. Support by chat or email if you want help.
Install free